Catfish Annie's

About Catfish Annie's

Located at 116 Commack Rd in Commack, New York, Catfish Annie's is a seafood restaurant. It's part of our guide to 28 restaurants, cafes and bars in Commack. Prices are mid-range ($20–30 per person).

Catfish Annie's is open 5 days a week, usually 11:00 AM – 7:30 PM (closed Monday and Tuesday).

Catfish Annie's's menu features 10 dishes and drinks across 5 sections, including Appetizers, Sandwiches, Fried Fish Dinners, Chicken Beef, and Soups. Listed prices range from $6.00 to $18.95, with a typical item around $10.95. You will find options like Fried Calamari, Crab Cake Sandwich, and Fish Cakes.

Available service options are on-site services, takeaway, and dine-in. Visitors describe the atmosphere as casual, cosy, and quiet, and it is a good fit for groups, locals, and tourists. It is especially popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Offerings include beer, coffee, comfort food, healthy options, and quick bite.

Accessibility features: wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible entrance, wheelchair-accessible seating, and assistive hearing loop. Payment methods accepted: credit cards and debit cards. Parking: free of charge street parking, free parking lot, and parking. Reservations are accepted; call (631) 499-5131 to book a table.

Quick facts

Category

Seafood Restaurant

Address

116 Commack Rd, Commack, NY 11725

Phone

(631) 499-5131

Price range

$20–30 per person

Hours

Open 5 days a week, usually 11:00 AM – 7:30 PM (closed Monday and Tuesday)

Menu

10 items · $6.00–$18.95

Listing updated

May 2026 · Suggest an edit

How the hours compare

We compared Catfish Annie's’s weekday schedule with 118 other seafood restaurants in New York. On a typical weekday it opens at 11:00 AM, earlier than 65% of them (the typical opening time is 12:00 PM) and closes at 7:30 PM, earlier than most (typical closing time: 10:00 PM).

In total it is open about 44.5 hours a week, 17 hours fewer than the local median of 62. 87% of seafood restaurants in New York open on Sundays, and Catfish Annie's is one of them.

Compared with 118 other seafood restaurants in New York that list their hours in our guide.

• Fried Calamari$8.95

  Squid.

• Crab Cake Sandwich$9.95
• Fish Cakes$14.95
• Hamburger$10.95

  Cooked to order. With French fried and coleslaw, lettuce and tomato. Meat Temperature: Medium, Medium Rare…

• Seafood Bisque Soup$6.00

  Pint.

• Mussels Marinara$10.95
• Fried Scallops Sandwich$10.95
• Shrimp$18.95
• Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana$14.95

  Served with linguini.

• Manhattan Clam Chowder Soup$6.00

  Pint.

Typical prices for seafood restaurants in New York

Based on 40 menus with 2,316 priced items from seafood restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $15.95, and half of all items are priced between $9.00 and $24.00.

At Catfish Annie's the median listed price is $10.95, lower than the typical $15.95 for seafood restaurants in New York.

Calculated from 40 menus in our guide. Prices vary by location and change over time.

Features & amenities

The neighborhood

Within a 10-minute walk (half a mile) of Catfish Annie's there are 11 other places to eat and drink in our guide, and 16 within one mile. By type, the places within a mile include Burgers & Fast Food (3), American (3), Bars & Pubs (2), and Mediterranean & Middle Eastern (2).

6 places within a mile stay open until 10 PM or later on at least one night a week, so this is a good area for a late meal.

Nearest places of other kinds

• ChineseFoo Luck< 0.1 mi
• AmericanRedefine Meals0.1 mi
• Sandwiches & DelisBagel Chalet0.2 mi
• Mediterranean & Middle EasternAthenian Greek Taverna0.3 mi
• Burgers & Fast FoodBurgerFi0.4 mi

No visitor reviews yet. Been to Catfish Annie's? Share your experience to help other diners.

More reviews on:GoogleInstagramTripadvisorYelp